Expand 2x Expand hover 2x
Close sidemenu Close sidemenu hover
Contents
  1. I. Introduction (30m)
  2. II. Basic Reporting (60m)
  3. III. Basic Storytelling (30m)
Resources

Basic Toolkit / Finding a Solutions-Oriented Story

Slices

Slices

Despite the emphasis on data journalism in the last few years, some journalists still shy away from large datasets. And when journalists do turn to data, it’s often to investigate a negative outlier. Data usually informs journalistic inquiries like: What city has the worst crime rate? Where is governance the weakest? Where are racial and economic inequalities the greatest?

We suggest a different way for journalists to use data — exploring positive deviants, or slices of a dataset that get at the best performers. For example: Which hospital in Texas has the lowest infection rate? In which state is recidivism the lowest? What country has the highest participation of women in government?

A positive deviant is a signal that something newsworthy could be happening. It’s the journalist’s job to get the story behind the positive deviant — and in so doing, uncover information that could be valuable for people everywhere. Perhaps the Texas hospital found a way to encourage nurses to speak up when a doctor fails to wash hands. Maybe state prison authorities began providing mental- health services and drug treatment to recently released prisoners. Those are important stories. (That being said, a positive deviant could also signify nothing. It could be a quirk in the data, a function of demographics, or an inaccurate measurement. As we said, it’s the journalist’s job to find out!)

Positive deviant journalism works backwards from data outcomes. Some journalists hesitate to attempt solutions journalism because they fear being labeled advocates or PR representatives. But with positive deviant journalism, the data will guide you to a story — and therefore will refute any confusion with advocacy.

Next time you look at a dataset, here are a few ways to consider slicing it to find a noteworthy positive deviant. This table is not meant to be exhaustive, but rather to spur your imagination a bit.

Strategy Description STORY EXAMPLES
Change Over Time
Which place has made newsworthy improvement?
Comparison to Peers
Which place is doing better than its comparable peers?
Method/Best Practice
Which place is succeeding with innovative new ideas?

From Class to Career

WAMU Breaking Ground

Coverage
Which place has greatly expanded access to a solution?
Subgroup
Which place has improved outcomes for a particular population?
Policy
Which government has instituted successful new policies to solve a problem?
Disparity
Which place has reduced racial, geographic or socioeconomic disparities in outcomes?
Cost
Which place has maintained good service while reducing costs?
4 Comments

  • Mary Agoyi

    Thank you for this table of disparity.

  • Jeremías Aspen

    Tendré siempre a mano esta tabla para estimularme a encontrar historias de desviaciones positivas.

  • Kepher Otieno

    This is awe inspiring, from a hermeneutical approach and comparative advantages

  • Kepher Otieno

    This is awe inspiring, from a hermeneutical approach and comparative advantages

Resources

Small x 2x Small x hover 2x

“I approached the entire project differently than I might otherwise have. I began to ask sources questions about positive variants, rather than negative, and paid attention to those anecdotes. I used this information to focus in on the topic I would write about.”

Ameliaschonbek
Amelia Schonbek
Journalist
Reporting Instructively on Failure

Bringing a Solutions Lens to Short Pieces